Black Swan Observatory

Bank of Japan Exit From Negative Rates

reviewed Illustrative example Validated

example-macro · written 2024-03-05 · vintage 2024-03-05 close · review due 2024-04-30

Post-mortem review: Validated

Conducted as of 2024-04-30

Validated. On 19 March 2024 the Bank of Japan raised its policy rate out of negative territory and ended yield curve control. No purchase operation outside the published plan was announced. The largest daily change in the 10-year yield over the window was 0.05 percentage points. The memo said nothing about the yen, which weakened after the decision instead of strengthening. A currency-based reading of the exit would have been wrong.

Thesis Taxonomy
Primary Archetype: Inflation / Rate Shock Contrary Archetype: Policy Credibility
The Bank of Japan will end negative interest rates by 30 April 2024 without a disorderly sell-off in Japanese government bonds.
Empirical Base Rate Anchor
Unconditional (study) 7%
Conditional (desk estimate) 5%
Unconditional rate from ghss-2022. The conditional rate is the author's judgment, not a study result.
Risk & Falsification
Desk Assumption:

Hold a small position for higher Japanese yields; no leverage, given the risk of a disorderly move.

3 Falsification Triggers:
  • The Bank of Japan policy rate is still negative after its April 2024 meeting.
  • The Bank of Japan announces a bond purchase operation outside its published monthly purchase plan, including any fixed-rate purchase operation, between 6 March and 30 April 2024 inclusive.
  • The 10-year yield in the Ministry of Finance daily series rises by 0.15 percentage points or more from one trading day's close to the next, between 6 March and 30 April 2024 inclusive.

Watched official releases 1

Illustrative example. This memo was written in October 2026, after the outcome was known, to show how a desk memo works. Its pre-event sections use only information public on 5 March 2024. It is not part of the desk’s track record and is excluded from the hit rate.

Hypothesis

The Bank of Japan’s policy rate has been -0.1% since 2016, and it still runs yield curve control. Officials have signalled that an exit depends on wage growth. The first results of this year’s spring wage talks are due in mid-March.

The memo argues the exit will come by the end of April and will be orderly. The Bank has prepared markets for months, and domestic investors hold most government bonds.

Contrary reading

Under POLICY_CREDIBILITY_CRISIS, ending yield curve control removes the anchor on long yields. A sharp sell-off would then force the Bank to step back in.

Base rate

Greenwood, Hanson, Shleifer and Sørensen (2022) find a 3-year crisis probability of about 7% in normal times. The 5% conditional figure is this desk’s own judgment that the exit triggers a crisis. It is not a result from the study.

Falsification criteria

  1. The policy rate is still negative after the April 2024 meeting.
  2. The Bank of Japan announces a bond purchase operation outside its published monthly purchase plan, including any fixed-rate purchase operation, between 6 March and 30 April 2024 inclusive.
  3. The 10-year yield in the Ministry of Finance daily series rises by 0.15 percentage points or more from one trading day’s close to the next, between 6 March and 30 April 2024 inclusive.

The 0.15-point threshold is the largest daily rise in that series from 2013 to this memo’s date. It happened on 20 December 2022, when the Bank unexpectedly widened its yield band.

A higher yield level alone does not falsify the thesis. Only a disorderly move does.

Post-mortem (30 April 2024)

  • Outcome: validated.
  • What happened: the Bank of Japan ended negative rates and yield curve control on 19 March 2024. No purchase operation outside the published plan was announced. In the Ministry of Finance series, the largest daily change in the 10-year yield over the window was 0.05 percentage points.
  • What the memo missed: it ignored the yen, which weakened after the decision instead of strengthening.